Matt the Miller’s Tavern Review | Carmel, IN

Matt the Miller's Tavern_Classic Margherita Flatbread

Matt the Miller’s Tavern is located in a new building in the City Center area of Carmel, Indiana at the corner of Rangeline Road and 126th Street, and they also have locations in Grandview and Dublin, Ohio.  Their restaurants have a little bit of something for everyone making them hard to classify, but I would consider them to be an upscale […]

Donatello’s Italian Restaurant Review | Carmel, IN

Donatello's Italian Restaurant_Sausage and Garlic Pizza

  Donatello’s Italian Restaurant is located in Carmel’s Arts & Design Distict and boasts a recently expanded restaurant and menu.  The expansion of their restaurant included adding outdoor dining and a coffee lounge.  However, the most important expansion, to me at least, was adding pizza to their menu.  I would classify Donatello’s food as being […]

Kona Grill Review | Carmel, IN

Kona Grill_Pepperoni Pizza

Kona Grill in Carmel, Indiana is located within Clay Terrace, an outdoor shopping mall, and they also currently have locations within fifteen other states.  Kona Grill is most well-known for their sushi, but I appreciate that they serve pizza, sandwiches, and other dishes as well.  Being that I am in fact The Pizza Fan, and not The Sushi […]

Toppers Review | Carmel, IN

Toppers - Ultimate Pepperoni Topper

Toppers Pizza just opened a new location in Carmel, Indiana off of Carmel Drive in between Pennsylvania and Meridian Streets.  They had some fun giveaways on their opening day, including free food for a year to the first fifty people in line, and some of their pizzas, such as the Mac ‘N Cheese, further show their […]

BoomBozz Review | Carmel, IN

BoomBozz Pizza_Ham and Bacon

  The BoomBozz Taphouse location I visited just recently opened in Carmel, Indiana and there is also a location in Gilbert, Arizona as well as four in Louisville, Kentucky where Famous BoomBozz Pizza started.   My meal began with pretzels and beer cheese which were incredibly good.  My tip is to save their house made beer cheese to dip your crust into […]

Macaroni Grill Review | Carmel, IN

Romano's Macaroni Grill - Pepperoni Pizza

Romano’s Macaroni Grill is an Italian restaurant chain with locations throughout most of the United States, and I dined at the one in Carmel, Indiana. Like many Italian restaurants, Macaroni Grill starts you out with very good fresh bread and olive oil. We followed that up with their Mac & Cheese Bites appetizer which consisted […]

Luca Pizza | Carmel, IN

Luca Pizza_PizzaReview

Luca Pizza is a pretty new pizza place in Carmel that offers New York-style pizza. You can grab a quick slice or two or order entire pies there, and I would recommend a whole pizza as otherwise the slices are pre-made and just warmed up. I think the best thing they offer is their pepperoni […]

Charleston’s Restaurant | Carmel, In

Charleston's Restaurant_Pizza Review

Charleston’s Restaurant is a great place to enjoy a nice dinner. They offer a variety of food ranging from sandwhiches to prime rib as well as a wide range of beer and wine. The pizza is listed as a starter, but it is filling enough to be your meal. It was a pretty good pizza, […]

Puccini’s Smiling Teeth | Carmel, IN

Puccini's Smiling Teeth_PizzaReview

Puccini’s Smiling Teeth offers various Italian dishes along with beer and wine. Their pizza is pretty good, and they scored points with me by allowing me to substitute a second slice of pizza in replacement of the salad on their lunch special. I recommend the Sweet Lil’ Razorback (pepperoni, smoked sausage, bacon, with a lil’ […]

Carrabba’s Italian Grill | CLOSED

Carrabba's Italian Grill_Pizza_Review

4/3/2013 Update – Unfortunately, the Carrabba’s in Carmel closed a little while ago.  They do still have Indiana locations in Mishawaka and Southport as well restaurants in thirty-one other states though. Carrabba’s Italian Grill gets The Pizza Fan’s recommendation for a quality date restaurant where you can still get good pizza. I think Carrabba’s can help […]