I briefly lived in Wisconsin, and during that time Glass Nickel Pizza was a staple of my diet (along with beer and cheese curds). My favorite of their pizzas is one with pepperoni and extra cheese as it creates an amazingly delicious and greasy pizza. Aside from the good amount of cheese, their pizzas are not all that heavy which helps to aid in the thought of there always being room for one more slice. Most Glass Nickel Pizza locations have very little eat-in area, but it is worth getting for carryout or delivery. I definitely recommend trying Glass Nickel Pizza if you are in the Madison, Green Bay, or Milwaukee areas as those are currently their only locations.
What I Ate: Pepperoni and Extra Cheese
Glass Nickel Pizza Company
13175 W Bluemound Rd
Brookfield, WI 53005