Greek Tony’s Pizza and Sub Shop | Carmel, IN

Greek Tony’s Pizza and Sub Shop offers a nice local feel with great pizza.  The pictured pizza is their thin and crispy crust, but they have other options.  If you enjoy greasy and buttery breadsticks, then you have to order the breadsticks at Greek Tony’s Pizza and Sub Shop.  However, if you are one who worries about your arteries, then you may not want to have too many of these delicious breadsticks (one is pictured below surrounded by the glorious garlic butter).

What I Ate: Pepperoni
Rating: 8.0/10.0

Greek Tony’s Pizza and Sub Shop
1732 E 116TH St
Carmel, IN 46032




About Ryan Hays

My name is Ryan, and I am the creator of I am in search of the greatest pizza in America, and I will take you along for the ride through this website. Please let me know your thoughts as I would be happy to hear your input.


  1. Kelly H says:

    And then you were gonna say how your friend Kelly LOVES Greek Tony’s even though she calls it Tony the Greeks. FACT: Pizza tastes better served on a table with a plastic red checkered table covering. FACT: Unless your pizza sucks and then no one can help you. Not even BEER can help you. BEER may make PEOPLE look prettier occasionally but NOTHING can help bad pizza, not hot sauce, not ranch dressing, not even FREE pizza can help you if your PIZZA is bad. Thank GOODNESS we have Ryan here to protect us. Thanks Ryan. And Ryan…I think Tony the Greek’s is better than an 8. If you go again and it’s even better than you remember can you re-post it with a better score? And could we have a breadstick rating system put in place please? I think it’s important.

  2. Kelly H says:

    Great picture BTW!

  3. Kelly H says:

    I give that picture an 8.0

  4. lakisha says:

    omg… i just tried the breadsticks and im in love .. hands down the best breadsticks i have ever had
    it’s not greasy its a garlic butter sauce to die for .. They are served hot with cheese sauce on the side and you won’t dip on every bite because these breadsticks are good all by themselves the cheese just adds more flavor

  5. c.k says:

    I ate here and they had the worst customer service ever. The soup was poor in taste and supervisor had no comment or resolution to the issue. I will never eat here again!

Speak Your Mind