New York Pizza Garden | Fishers, IN

New York Pizza Garden recently opened in a small strip mall just off of IN-37 and 126th Street in Fishers.  Oddly enough, it is in the same strip mall that houses Big Apple Bagels.  New York Pizza Garden has a small eat-in area, and they offer pizza-by-the-slice for those who want to grab a quick bite.  I would recommend carry-out or delivery as better options though.   They don’t just do pizza either, and their garden apparently also includes wings, various starters, calzones, gyros, pasta, and even burgers.  I sampled the garlic knots from their starter menu, and I was impressed with them.  I think some restaurants’ garlic knots are too dry, but these were moist and flavorful.

New York Pizza Garden has some good coupons on the back of their menu, and I took advantage of the one for a large cheese pizza for only $5.99.  I felt that they were pretty generous with the quantity of cheese unlike some New York-style pizzerias, and I also found the cheese to pretty tasty.  My one complaint would be that the pizza had a fairly large and doughy crust.  It didn’t taste bad, but a smaller crust leaving more room for toppings or a dipping sauce for the crust would have made it better in my opinion.  I didn’t have the highest expectations for New York Pizza Garden since it is just a small place in a little strip mall, but I would say that their food was actually slightly better than what I expected.  I would not hesitate to order delivery or carry-out from them again if I want decent New York-style pizza without the New York-style price.

What I Ate: Cheese
Rating: 6.5/10

New York Pizza Garden
9522 E. 126 Street
Fishers, IN 46038

About Ryan Hays

My name is Ryan, and I am the creator of I am in search of the greatest pizza in America, and I will take you along for the ride through this website. Please let me know your thoughts as I would be happy to hear your input.


  1. Skylar Gadd says:

    Hi my name is Skylar Gadd the new General Manager/operator of New York Style pizzeria garden, we would love new feedback of becoming of a new pizza place/restaurant. Please come by and taste many of our delightful dishes, I promise that you will find something you love if not all of our items. We have made some slight changes to our items by many of our new expertise workers/management team. I highly recommend our New York style pizza, Stromboli’s, calzones, cheesy sticks, salads, wings, lasagna, spaghetti, and our deserts. Great things are coming along to our successful path to becoming the greatest pizza place in Hamilton County

  2. Dee says:

    I Love this place! This is a family owned business with great Healthy food! All the food is made with LOVE and you can taste it in every bite…

Speak Your Mind