Ono’s Pizza | CLOSED

Pizza_Ranking_Ono's

4/4/2013 Update – I guess I could say I told you so as Ono’s Pizza is no longer in business. Ono’s Pizza offers decent pizza, but, to be honest, it tasted like something I could make on my own.  There is nothing particularly wrong with the pizza, however it is just somewhat bland.  I had One’s […]

Roselli’s | Carmel, IN

IN - Roselli's

If you are on the northside of Indianapolis and want to go to a pizza buffet, then you need to look no further than Roselli’s.  Roselli’s is located at 106th and Michigan on the southwest side of Carmel, essentially on the Zionsville border.  Not only do they offer delicious thin crust pizza, but they typically have one […]

Monical’s Pizza Restaurant

IN - Monical's Pizza Restaurant

Monical’s Pizza offers good thin and pan-style crust pizza.  I don’t believe all of their locations offer a buffet, but the one in Carmel did until it closed (there are rumors about it reopening elsewhere though).  It is certainly one of the better overall buffets, but that also shows in its price by comparison.  They save […]

Bella Pizzeria | Carmel, IN

IN - Bella Pizzeria

Bella Pizzeria is worth a try if you like New York style pizza.  However, it was a little heavy on dough and light on cheese and toppings for my taste.  Bella Pizzeria offers whole pies as pictured and individual slices.  Located in Clay Terrace, an outdoor mall, this would be a great place to grab a slice […]

Some Guy’s Pizza Pasta Grill | Carmel, IN

IN - Some Guys Pizza Pasta Grill

Some Guy’s Pizza offers very good pizza with a crust similar to Bazbeaux’s as well as quality toppings.  I am told that the owner of Some Guy’s used to work at Bazbeaux Pizza, and while the pizza is delicious, I couldn’t give the spin-off quite as good of a rating as the original.  Please don’t mistake this for […]

Papa John’s | Carmel, IN

IN - Papa John's

I would say Papa John’s does a good job of having fresh-tasting pizzas as compared to their large chain competitors.  I think the garlic dipping sauce is a nice touch as their standard crust isn’t too flavorful otherwise.  They do offer thin crust as well, but then you lose out on the garlic dipping sauce.  […]

Fazoli’s | Carmel, IN

IN - Fazolis

Aside from that brief period when they charged you a quarter for breadsticks, I have always been a huge fan of Fazolis.  They have changed their pizza recipe quite a few times over the years, but I think the current one is pretty good.  It is a fairly greasy pizza with a hint of their breadstick […]

HotBox Pizza | Carmel, IN

IN - HotBox Pizza

HotBox Pizza, also known as Pizza Express at some southern Indiana loacations, offers solid pizza options with breadsticks that are particularly popular in the college town locations (Bloomington, West Lafayette, Broad Ripple, and South Bend).  Having enjoyed these breadsticks more times than I can remember while attending Indiana University, I certainly recommend getting the special […]

Donatos | Carmel, IN

Donatos_Pepperoni Pizza

Donatos has to be my favorite pizza among the fairly large chains.  They have a delicious thin crust with an amazing amount of tasty pepperoni.  They put some sort of seasoning on top of their pepperoni that really makes it stand out from others.  Donatos is a little more expensive than most chains, but I think it […]

Bazbeaux Pizza | Carmel, IN

Bazbeaux Pizza_Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza

Basbeaux Pizza has been people’s choice for the best pizza in Indianapolis every year since it’s opening in 1986, and I could not agree with the people more on this one.  My personal favorites from this establishment are the simple sausage and pepperoni pizza (pictured above) or their margherita pizza (pictured below).  Their pizza alla quattro formaggio seems to […]