Bass Lake Pub & Ristorante | Knox, IN

Bass Lake Pub & Ristorante_Sausage Pizza

The Bass Lake Pub & Ristorante offers pretty good pizza with a local, small restaurant feel. The pizza has a traditional thickness crust that isn’t too special, but the cheese and toppings are solid. Do not let the term “ristorante” trick you into thinking it is a fancy place. That is not meant to be […]

Chatham Tap Restaurant & Pub | Indianapolis, IN

Chatham Tap_Indianapolis_Pizza

The Chatham Tap Restaurant & Pub is a fun English pub with a location on Massachusetts Avenue in Indianapolis and one in Fishers. They serve sandwiches, melts, burgers, and pizza. While I don’t think they are that well known for their pizza, The Meaty Kuzola was very good. The Chatham Tap also has a large […]

Carrabba’s Italian Grill | CLOSED

Carrabba's Italian Grill_Pizza_Review

4/3/2013 Update – Unfortunately, the Carrabba’s in Carmel closed a little while ago.  They do still have Indiana locations in Mishawaka and Southport as well restaurants in thirty-one other states though. Carrabba’s Italian Grill gets The Pizza Fan’s recommendation for a quality date restaurant where you can still get good pizza. I think Carrabba’s can help […]

Domino’s Pizza | Westfield, IN

Domino's Pizza_Review_Westfield

I think Domino’s Pizza did a great job making their crust better when they went through their upgrade; it has some butter and seasoning that makes it pretty good. I think everything else tastes fairly similar, but as long as their prices stay the same then Domino’s is a great option for a decent tasting […]

Pizza Hut | Carmel, IN

Pizza Hut_Buffet

4/3/2013 Update – Unfortunately, the Pizza Hut at 1344 South Rangeline Road in Carmel that offered the buffet has closed.  However, they do still have a carryout and delivery location at 705 South Rangeline Road in Carmel.  The closest Pizza Hut restaurants with dine-in options and the lunch buffet are in Indianapolis, Fishers, and Noblesville. […]

Mellow Mushroom | Carmel, IN

Mellow Mushroom_Pizza_Rating

Mellow Mushroom is an interestingly themed restaurant that offers a fair amount of specialty pizzas as well as numerous different topping options for customers to build their own creations. I enjoyed their crust as they have some seasoning on it that tasted like garlic butter and parmesan to me (whatever it was added some nice […]

Union Jack Pub | Indianapolis, IN

Union Jack Pub_Indianapolis_Pizza

I am pretty sure I could actually live at Union Jack Pub as they offer traditional crust pizza, New York thin crust pizza, Chicago-style deep dish pizza, and stuffed pizza! Additionally, they have several speciality pizzas, and you can even get a breakfast pizza on Sunday morning. I was somewhat boring when I went to […]

Tony Sacco’s Coal Oven Pizza | Carmel, IN

Tony Sacco's_Pizza_Carmel_Rating

Tony Sacco’s Coal Oven Pizza has great crust and sauce, but their pizzas are somewhat light on cheese and toppings in more of a traditional style. The pizzas are baked in a coal fired oven at about 1000 degrees for four minutes, and the sauce is made fresh daily from Italian plum tomatoes. The Pizza […]

Greek’s Pizzeria | Carmel, IN

Greek's Pizzeria_Indianapolis_Review

Greek’s Pizzeria makes good pizza with a delicious garlic butter crust. I also really enjoyed their garlic breadsticks (you may be picking up on the fact that a garlic theme wins over my tastebuds). I visited the Broad Ripple location which, unfortunately, has since closed, but I believe Greek’s started in Muncie. They also have […]

Kilroy’s Bar N’ Grill | Indianapolis, IN

Kilroy's Bar N' Grill_Pizza_Review

Kilroy’s Bar N’ Grill is a fun bar in the Wholesale District of downtown Indianapolis. The original location is just off of Indiana University’s campus in Bloomington, and the Indianapolis location features most of the same speciality drinks, only without the low prices of a college town.  The downtown Indy Kilroy’s is very close to Banker’s Life […]