Firehouse Pizza | Westfield, IN

IN - Firehouse Pizza

Firehouse Pizza makes a decent pizza with a fairly thin crust. They do a great job of loading on sausage if you choose to make it one of your toppings, but my main complaint would be that the crust lacks much flavor. Firehouse Pizza has locations in Carmel, Fishers, and Noblesville in addition to the […]

Ale Emporium | Indianapolis, IN

Ale Emporium_Pizza Review

The size and atmosphere of the Ale Emporium are very impressive considering that it is located in a strip mall. Moreover, it might boast some of the best tasting pizza I have ever had inside of a restaurant with such an unassuming exterior. They offer pan and thin crust pizza. However, I have only had […]

‘Za | Indianapolis, IN

'Za_Broad Ripple_Pizza Review

‘Za is a small pizzeria in Broad Ripple that serves New York-style pizza. ‘Za’s pizza is fairly average, but it could be even better at certain times. If you enjoy being frugal, then you should go to ‘Za for their five dollar lunch special between 11 am and 2 pm. This special includes a slice, […]

Cafe Pizzaria | Bloomington, IN

Cafe Pizzaria_PizzaReview_Bloomington

Cafe Pizzaria has been serving pizzas in Bloomington with the same recipe since 1953, and it certainly has a neat college town restaurant feel with some nice Indiana University memorabilia. I believe they may have lost some popularity in recent years, but they still make a decent thin crust pizza. While I obviously had their […]

Syd’s Bar | Noblesville, IN

Syd's Bar_PizzaReview

Syd’s is an older bar on the square of downtown Noblesville. They gained my respect for serving pizza even after the kitchen is closed (for everyone, not just The Pizza Fan). The pizza isn’t too special as it is just somewhat of a typical bar pizza. However, it does have a nice amount of cheese […]

Harry and Izzy’s | Indianapolis, IN

Harry & Izzy's in the Indianapolis Airport_Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza

Harry & Izzy’s and its sister restaurant, St. Elmos, are staples of Indianapolis.  That combined with the fact that the Indianapolis International Airport doesn’t have a lot of options for pizza, makes the Harry & Izzy’s location in the A concourse of the airport pretty attractive.  Their pizzas are more of a personal-size, but they feature a […]

Sporty’z Grill & Bar | Knox, IN

Sporty'z Grill & Bar_Pepperoni Pizza

Sporty’z Grill & Bar on Bass Lake in Knox, Indiana makes pretty good pizza served in a restaurant with lots of flare. I certainly recommend that you eat in to enjoy the scenary. I’ll work to try to add pictures in the future, but you will just have to trust me for now that they have a […]

Shebella’s Pizza & Deli | CLOSED

Shebella's Pizza & Deli_PizzaReview

Update – Unfortunately Shebella’s Pizza & Deli closed after only about seven months of being in business. Shebella’s Pizza & Deli is a somewhat new restaurant in northern Indianapolis. They offer a good amount of speciality pizzas and sandwiches, but I visited them for their dinner buffet. The pizza is better than it looks in […]

Pizza King | Anderson, IN

Pizza King_PizzaReview

Pizza King is a fairly famous pizza parlor in some of the smaller towns across Indiana. Their slogan of “Ring the King” is backed up by the fact that you can place your order via phones that are placed in each booth. The Pizza King in Anderson made a great pizza, and it had a […]

Luca Pizza | Carmel, IN

Luca Pizza_PizzaReview

Luca Pizza is a pretty new pizza place in Carmel that offers New York-style pizza. You can grab a quick slice or two or order entire pies there, and I would recommend a whole pizza as otherwise the slices are pre-made and just warmed up. I think the best thing they offer is their pepperoni […]