Best Pizza in Hamilton County

I’ve had a lot of pizza in Hamilton County, Indiana, so I thought it would be worth sharing some my favorite pizza places by its major cities:

CarmelBazbeaux Pizza makes award-winning pizza in downtown Carmel.

Fishers – Rockstone Pizzeria & Pub offers great pizza and beer, and they take my #1 spot in Fishers from Nancy’s which has closed.

WestfieldJan’s Village Pizza serves fresh pizza in a friendly atmosphere.

NoblesvilleCool River Pizza boasts an expanded restaurant with the same great pizza.

Please leave me your thoughts on the best pizza in Hamilton County as I would be very interested to hear about any restaurants I have not mentioned.  I will also accept comments telling my how accurate my list is and how incredibly smart I am :).

About Ryan Hays

My name is Ryan, and I am the creator of I am in search of the greatest pizza in America, and I will take you along for the ride through this website. Please let me know your thoughts as I would be happy to hear your input.


  1. Troy says:

    Your list is great and your smart, I like Cool River Pizza the best.

  2. Kelly says:

    Troy is right, you are smart. And you are right. CRP is DEluxe!

  3. Carla Shadiow says:

    Ryan, try Apezza at Geist (Brooks School Road and Fall Creek Road) I love the high-fiber pizza – lots of veggies! I donated $10 so you can try it ;)

Speak Your Mind