Pizza 317 | Carmel, IN


Pizza 317 is a new addition to the northeast Carmel pizza scene.  I imagine most of its business is delivery or carryout, but it does have some limited seating as well. Most of the items on the menu at Pizza 317 are named after something relating to central Indiana.  I started with the Colts Cheese […]

Shoefly Public House | Indianapolis, IN

Shoefly Public House_Cuban Pretzel Flatbread

My Cuban Pretzel Flatbread at Shoefly Public House really pushed the boundaries of what can evenly remotely be considered pizza, but I found the restaurant and this dish worthy of a post nonetheless.  Shoefly is located at 22nd and Talbott Street in Indianapolis and was created to offer this area a place for a quick […]

Giorgio’s Pizza | Indianapolis, IN

Giorgio's Pizza_New York-Style and Sicilian-Style Slices

Giorgio’s Pizza opened in 1990 and is just east of Monument Circle in downtown Indianapolis.  It was neat to see Giorgio himself still working there, although the staff wasn’t very friendly overall.  In addition to salads, pasta, and subs, Giorgio’s offers both Sicilian thick crust pizza and Neopolitan thin crust pizza (basically New York-style) by the […]

Latitude 39 Review | Indianapolis, IN

Latitude 39_Pepperoni Pizza

Latitude 39 is a new entertainment venue/restaurant in Indianapolis, Indiana that offers everything from skeeball to pizza.  One could truly be entertained for hours at Latitude 39 as they have an arcade, bowling alley, cinema, sports theater, bar with live music, and more.  Latitude 39 can be thought of as a Dave & Busters on steroids that is also a little more upscale.  It […]

Donatello’s Italian Restaurant Review | Carmel, IN

Donatello's Italian Restaurant_Sausage and Garlic Pizza

  Donatello’s Italian Restaurant is located in Carmel’s Arts & Design Distict and boasts a recently expanded restaurant and menu.  The expansion of their restaurant included adding outdoor dining and a coffee lounge.  However, the most important expansion, to me at least, was adding pizza to their menu.  I would classify Donatello’s food as being […]

Casler’s Kitchen & Bar Review | Fishers, IN

Casler's Kitchen & Bar_The White Pizza

Casler’s Kitchen & Bar in Fishers, Indiana offers a wide variety of food and plenty of televsions.  The pizza that Casler’s is known for is The White Pizza which consists of a sharp cheddar sauce, grilled chicken, bacon, mushrooms, red onions, and mozzarella cheese.  I was extremely pleased with the way the savory sharp cheddar sauce […]

Matteo’s Ristorante Italiano | Noblesville, IN

IN - Matteo's Ristorante Italiano

Matteo’s is a very nice restaurant on the square in Noblesville. It is known for its fine Italian cuisine, and, while pizza is only listed as an appetizer, I found it to be very good considering it is not what this restaurant specializes in. The pizza has a nice soft crust and packs a lot of […]

Cafe Pizzaria | Bloomington, IN

Cafe Pizzaria_PizzaReview_Bloomington

Cafe Pizzaria has been serving pizzas in Bloomington with the same recipe since 1953, and it certainly has a neat college town restaurant feel with some nice Indiana University memorabilia. I believe they may have lost some popularity in recent years, but they still make a decent thin crust pizza. While I obviously had their […]

Charleston’s Restaurant | Carmel, In

Charleston's Restaurant_Pizza Review

Charleston’s Restaurant is a great place to enjoy a nice dinner. They offer a variety of food ranging from sandwhiches to prime rib as well as a wide range of beer and wine. The pizza is listed as a starter, but it is filling enough to be your meal. It was a pretty good pizza, […]

Carrabba’s Italian Grill | CLOSED

Carrabba's Italian Grill_Pizza_Review

4/3/2013 Update – Unfortunately, the Carrabba’s in Carmel closed a little while ago.  They do still have Indiana locations in Mishawaka and Southport as well restaurants in thirty-one other states though. Carrabba’s Italian Grill gets The Pizza Fan’s recommendation for a quality date restaurant where you can still get good pizza. I think Carrabba’s can help […]