Wise Pies Pizza & Subs | Terre Haute, IN

Wise Pies Pizza & Subs_Pepperoni and Carnivore Slices

Wise Pies serves New York-style pizza in Terre Haute, Indiana  They’ll certainly make your choice of pizza from scratch, but I took advantage of their premade pizza by-the-slice option.  If I had more time, I wouldn’t have done this because I’ve seen the reheating of these slices negatively affect the consistency of the crust at many […]

New York Pizza Garden | Fishers, IN

New York Pizza Garden_Cheese Pizza

New York Pizza Garden recently opened in a small strip mall just off of IN-37 and 126th Street in Fishers.  Oddly enough, it is in the same strip mall that houses Big Apple Bagels.  New York Pizza Garden has a small eat-in area, and they offer pizza-by-the-slice for those who want to grab a quick bite.  I would […]

South of Chicago Pizza & Italian Beef | Fishers, IN

South of Chicago_Deep Dish Sausage Pizza

South of Chicago Pizza & Italian beef is rapidly trying to spread their Chicago-style pizza across the Indianapolis area.  They first opened in the Fletcher Place neighborhood of Indianapolis about three years ago, then they opened another location in Fishers’ Saxony at the beginning of 2014, and they now have plans to add a third restaurant in […]

Oobatz! Restaurant | Indianapolis, IN

Oobatz_Hoosier Daddy Pizza

Oobatz! Restaurant could best be described as a slightly upscale sports bar, and they have two locations in central Indiana – one in Zionsville and one at Keystone at the Crossing in Indianapolis.  There is a somewhat interesting color-changing mood lighting wall in their restaurant at Keystone at the Crossing that causes some odd changes in hue in my pictures […]

Marco’s Pizza | Westfield, IN

Marco's Pizza_Extra Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza

Marco’s Pizza just opened a new location in Westfield, Indiana, and they also already have locations in twenty-eight other states.  Their restaurant in Westfield offers some limited inside seating and is likely utilized more for carry out or delivery orders.  However, they do have a $5.99 lunch special – a six-inch sub, chips and a drink, a small salad […]

Aver’s Pizza Review | Bloomington, IN

Aver's Pizza_Pepperoni Pizza

Aver’s Pizza has three locations in Bloomington, Indiana; the Bloomington North and South locations offer carry out and delivery and their Bloomington East store also has a dining room.  I ordered the Crazy Aver’s Deal from their Bloomington North restaurant, and it included a twelve-inch medium one-topping pizza, breadsticks with one dipping sauce, two drinks, and two […]

Dante’s House of Pizza Review | Munster, IN

Dante's House of Pizza_Pepperoni Pizza

Dante’s House of Pizza is a pizza parlor in the northwestern Indiana town of Munster.  They have a lunch buffet on weekdays for $8.95 that I wish I could have tried, but I went there during dinner hours.  I started my dinner with some pretty good breadsticks, pictured below, and then I enjoyed the pepperoni […]

Moon Dog Tavern Review | Indianapolis, IN

Moon Dog Tavern_Indianapolis, IN_Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza

Moon Dog Tavern is a bar in the northside of Indianapolis that often features live music.  They offer a broad menu that includes appetizers, sandwichs, wraps, salads, and burgers.  I obviously had to try their pizza though, and I was pretty impressed with it considering it came from a bar kitchen that offers such a wide […]

Thr3e Wise Men Brewery | Indianapolis, IN

IN - Thr3e Wise Men Brewery

Thr3e Wise Men is a new microbrewery in the Broadripple area of Indianapolis. The inside has a neat cabin-type feel, and you can even be seated at picnic tables. I had their pizza lunch special which was a great deal as it also included three breadsticks (I recommend the stuffed ones), or salad if you […]

Shebella’s Pizza & Deli | CLOSED

Shebella's Pizza & Deli_PizzaReview

Update – Unfortunately Shebella’s Pizza & Deli closed after only about seven months of being in business. Shebella’s Pizza & Deli is a somewhat new restaurant in northern Indianapolis. They offer a good amount of speciality pizzas and sandwiches, but I visited them for their dinner buffet. The pizza is better than it looks in […]