Brother Doug’s Pizza Cafe | Fishers, IN

Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza, Sausage and Seasoned Pizza, and Cheese Strips

If you like small, family-owned and operated pizzerias, then Brother Doug’s Pizza is for you.  It offers the great qualities you’d expect of such an establishment, with friendly service and community involvement being the most obvious ones.  Brother Doug provided a great example of his community involvement during my visit by providing us with pink cookies to […]

Slimms Pizza and Salads | Fishers, IN

Sausage, Green Olive, and Garlic Pizza

Slimms Pizza and Salads is a recent addition to the fast custom pizza craze that seems to be sweeping the nation.  Their promise is to cook, cut, and serve your pizza in four minutes.  While this is similar to Blaze Pizza and Pie Five, what makes Slimms unique is that they are family-owned.  In fact, Slimms […]

Tomato Bar | Valparaiso, IN

Tomato Bar_Sausage, Green Olive, and Garlic Pizza

Tomato Bar in Valparaiso, Indiana serves appetizers, salads, sandwiches, and calzones, but their specialty is definitely pizza.  I will give them credit for having a pretty cool offering as far as salads go – a build your own option that has a huge amount of toppings to choose from.  Still, even that couldn’t get me to […]

V’s Pizza & Pasta | CLOSED

V's Pizza & Pasta_Grandma Pizza

I had been hearing good things about V’s Pizza & Pasta since they opened in Noblesville in January of 2014, so I was excited to check them out for myself.  They were very friendly and informative when I called in my order, but my enthusiasm dwindled slightly when I pulled into their parking lot and saw […]

Crust Pizzeria Napoletana | Carmel, IN

Crust in Carmel, IN_Soprano Pizza

Crust Pizzeria Napoletana, or simply Crust, just opened this week in Carmel, Indiana at the south end of the Providence Shoppes on Old Meridian.  As the full name implies, Crust strives to serve authentic Neopolitan pizza.  The owner personally cooks most of these pizzas in Crust’s stone oven that is kept at 700 degrees.  Before delving […]

Jimmy Stix | Carmel, IN

Jimmy Stix_Pepperoni and Sausage Sicilian Deep Dish Pizza

Jimmy Stix is a new family-owned pizzeria in Carmel, Indiana.  The owner previously owned Wise Guy’s Pizzeria but has since sold it in order to open up Jimmy Stix.  They have a friendly staff and a broad menu that features salads, wings, subs, calzones, pasta, and pizza.   They also serve their namesake “Jimmy Stix” as a starter, and […]

Zionsville Pizzeria | Zionsville, IN

Zionsville Pizzeria_Hand Tossed Pepperoni Pizza

Zionsville Pizzeria was previously known as Zionsville Pizza Delivery, and they have since grown to offer a sit down restaurant along with delivery.  Zionsville Pizzeria is in quaint downtown Zionsville, and it is a great example of a hometown pizzeria as the owners grew up in Zionsville and have raised their children there.  Its location […]

Big Mike’s Cafe Review | Indianapolis, IN

Big Mike's Cafe Americana_The Team G Pizza

Big Mike’s Cafe Americana is a family-owned restaurant located in an unassuming strip mall off of College Avenue on the far north side of Indianapolis.  I wasn’t sure what to expect for the interior of Big Mike’s given its location in an older-looking strip mall, but I was pleasantly surprised upon entering.  More importantly, my wife approved of […]

WB Pizza Review | Indianapolis, IN

WB Pizza_Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza

WB Pizza at 62nd and Allisonville in Indianapolis offers a cozy atmosphere and pizza known for its fresh ingredients – the dough and sauce used for their pizza is made daily using all natural ingredients.  I particularly enjoyed the sauce on my sausage and pepperoni pizza as I could tell it had some spices in […]

Buttitta’s Pizzeria Review | Fishers, IN

Buttitta's Pizzeria_Sausage and Pepperoni

Buttitta’s Italian Pizzeria is a nice family-owned and operated restaurant in Fishers, Indiana. Many of their ingredients are homemade including their sauce, dough, Italian sausage, meatballs, and beef. The fresh sauce and toppings really stood out on the sausage and pepperoni pizza I had that is pictured above. I also tried their prosciutto pizza (pictured […]